Sporadic reflections on values in Architecture, with an emphasis on sustainability
Showing posts with label Energy efficiency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Energy efficiency. Show all posts
Thursday, 22 January 2015
Wednesday, 10 April 2013
Too miraculous to be good - do surface coatings save lots of energy?
Having had my interest tweaked by allegations of falsified insulation values (see "The next insulation fiasco?"), and followed with questions about the certification of green materials (see Muddy green), it was almost fated that another niche market in the green building space would come to my attention. Actually, this one has been on my radar for a long time.
Quite small differences in the thermal properties of roofs and walls can disproportionately affect star ratings in voluntary schemes such as LEED and Australia's Green Star, and even more so in the mandatory energy efficiency measures for dwellings. Individual householders are becoming genuinely interested in energy efficiency improvements, as the cost of heating and cooling starts to bite. So they are excellent targets for advertised claims by manufacturers of paints and other painted-on coatings, promising reductions in energy use, and increased comfort.
The latest such claims came to my notice in on-line advertising by Nansulate®Energy Saving and Asset Protection Coatings of the USA. They describe "award-winning products powered by the science of nanotechnology" offering "a highly effective combination of benefits which include thermal insulation, corrosion resistance, mold resistance, moisture resistance, UV resistance, chemical resistance, flame resistance, and lead encapsulation", and claiming to provide "dramatic energy saving and protective solutions for industrial, commercial, government and residential customers around the world." The site provides a link to a supposed test ‘certificate’ here.
A colleague of mine, Associate Professor Alistair Sproul, is a physicist working with the new Cooperative Research Centre for Low Carbon Living, at the University of NSW, Sydney. He is pretty intimate with nano technologies, being a member of the world class photovoltaics team at the university, so he couldn't help himself when I pointed him at the Nansulate web site. He ran a few figures.
I only report here a small part of his first reaction. It starts with the observation that the independent measurements look a little internally inconsistent (the U value and R value changes agree with each other but the rate of heat transfer doesn’t agree with the stated R or U values). Bad start. Alistair is otherwise quite kind to the calculations, until he points out that "the implied thermal conductivity of the (Nansulate coating) layer k = L/R = 0.00085 W/mK – which is about 30 times lower than still air!" He goes on: "The best I have seen people claim for vacuum materials is something like 3 – 6 times lower than still air OR that the value will change with time."
At the risk of getting very technical, there are other factors which could contribute to improved thermal performance in the field. Principal amongst these is changed emissivity (the ability to get rid of heat by radiation) of the original surface, once coated. The scope for improvement is small in summer conditions, as the emissivity of most non-metalic building surfaces is already high. And surface emissivity plays little part in a standardised test for conductive heat transfer, which (to be fair) may be why it isn't mentioned in the test description.
I only report here a small part of his first reaction. It starts with the observation that the independent measurements look a little internally inconsistent (the U value and R value changes agree with each other but the rate of heat transfer doesn’t agree with the stated R or U values). Bad start. Alistair is otherwise quite kind to the calculations, until he points out that "the implied thermal conductivity of the (Nansulate coating) layer k = L/R = 0.00085 W/mK – which is about 30 times lower than still air!" He goes on: "The best I have seen people claim for vacuum materials is something like 3 – 6 times lower than still air OR that the value will change with time."
At the risk of getting very technical, there are other factors which could contribute to improved thermal performance in the field. Principal amongst these is changed emissivity (the ability to get rid of heat by radiation) of the original surface, once coated. The scope for improvement is small in summer conditions, as the emissivity of most non-metalic building surfaces is already high. And surface emissivity plays little part in a standardised test for conductive heat transfer, which (to be fair) may be why it isn't mentioned in the test description.
Suffice to say, at the end of the day I cannot satisfy myself that the claims of improved heat insulation, by putting on a thin translucent coating, are supported by the provided evidence. I have personal reasons to be incredulous.
Some years ago, I was in charge of a "test-cell" scale field test of the effects of a paint additive. We did find a small but likely real effect on heat transmission that could be attributed to the product. But the point of doing the tests outdoors on test cells was that we were in a position to interpret the results in terms of likely perceptions on thermal comfort, and possible energy savings. We reported to our paint manufacturer client that the effects were too small for them to rely on for marketing. So I wasn't surprised when recently the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) began proceedings against another paint manufacturer, Dulux, for alleged false and misleading paint advertising in relation to the promotion of the temperature reducing capabilities of its InfraCOOL and Weathershield Heat Reflect paints.
The problem, aside from the possibility of deliberate mis-representation, is that nobody I am aware of has yet offered a scientifically robust explanation for why these coatings and additives should work. In the absence of such theoretical explanation, we rely on 'empirical' tests of observed performance. In principle, there is nothing wrong with proceeding in this way, we are obliged to do this in much more critical examples in science (think the unexplained, but real effects of electroconvulsive therapy on clinical depression). It's just that you have to be scrupulous in your experiments, measurements and especially in your analysis.* And the claimed effect has to be worth it.
My clients benefited from an open mind, even if they were so desperate for a market position, that it took them a couple of years, and a court case, to resign themselves to my advice. Others are not necessarily so scrupulous. A consumer protection agency actually prosecuting for alleged misrepresentation is not exactly common, and will only happen at best after a lapse of some years. Individual consumers or specifiers are unlikely to have someone to turn to for credible expert checking of claims of improved performance. Unfortunately, a healthy cynicism is called for, which, even I am ready to admit, has its downside - I'd hate to miss the next good thing, just because I don't understand it.
The problem, aside from the possibility of deliberate mis-representation, is that nobody I am aware of has yet offered a scientifically robust explanation for why these coatings and additives should work. In the absence of such theoretical explanation, we rely on 'empirical' tests of observed performance. In principle, there is nothing wrong with proceeding in this way, we are obliged to do this in much more critical examples in science (think the unexplained, but real effects of electroconvulsive therapy on clinical depression). It's just that you have to be scrupulous in your experiments, measurements and especially in your analysis.* And the claimed effect has to be worth it.
My clients benefited from an open mind, even if they were so desperate for a market position, that it took them a couple of years, and a court case, to resign themselves to my advice. Others are not necessarily so scrupulous. A consumer protection agency actually prosecuting for alleged misrepresentation is not exactly common, and will only happen at best after a lapse of some years. Individual consumers or specifiers are unlikely to have someone to turn to for credible expert checking of claims of improved performance. Unfortunately, a healthy cynicism is called for, which, even I am ready to admit, has its downside - I'd hate to miss the next good thing, just because I don't understand it.
Footnotes
- For details of the Dulux case, click the ACCC link here.
- The Taubmans paints saga culminated in a court case, Freeworld Coatings Pty Ltd ats Worldwide Coatings lP Pty Ltd, which was settled with confidentiality agreements. But readers interested in the way such things happen, can read the original optimistic 'Eco-investment' assessment here.
- *BTW. What is the significance of the image at the start of the post? It is from a case study on the Nansulate web site. The text compares the heat loss at positions M1 (uncoated because it is inaccessible behind a radiator) with M2 (coated on the inside of the wall), as evidence of the effectiveness of the coating in reducing heat transfer. The alternative explanation, that the radiator is the source of the heat in the first place, and it is creating a much bigger temperature difference driving heat loss at that part of the wall, either escapes the person providing the analysis - or more likely is meant to escape the attention of the reader.
Saturday, 23 March 2013
Surprise. Surprise. Mandatory disclosure in New York
Sometimes it takes me a while to catch up with something quite important. And to be completely truthful, I wouldn't have caught up with this one, but for an item in GreenBuildingsAlive, a fine, 'long-form writing' blog I don't read nearly as much as it deserves.
Late last year, the New York Times carried an article on the results of the first mandatory disclosure of energy efficiency scores for commercial buildings. It had a few surprises. Chief amongst them were the unflattering comparisons between some newer buildings that have trumpeted high LEED ratings, and older buildings.
To me as an architect of a certain generation, there are other perhaps predictable, but still shocking factoids, mentioned in passing. My favourite? On a scale topping out at 100, "the Seagram Building, Mies van der Rohe’s bronze-toned 1958 masterpiece on Park Avenue, posted a 3." I shouldn't be surprised.
Read the NY Times article here.
And if you are up to it,download the whole 36 page NEW YORK CITY LOCAL LAW 84 BENCHMARKING REPORT in PDF format here.
Late last year, the New York Times carried an article on the results of the first mandatory disclosure of energy efficiency scores for commercial buildings. It had a few surprises. Chief amongst them were the unflattering comparisons between some newer buildings that have trumpeted high LEED ratings, and older buildings.
"In courting tenants over the last six years, 7 World Trade Center has trumpeted its gold LEED rating, an emblem of sound environmental citizenship. But when it comes to energy efficiency, the young 52-story tower . . . had a score of 74 — just below the minimum of 75 set for high-efficiency buildings by the federal Environmental Protection Agency’s Energy Star program.On the other hand, two venerated show horses from the 1930s, the Chrysler Building and the Empire State Building, sailed to an 84 and an 80 as a result of extensive upgrades of their insulation and mechanical systems."
Of course, the situation overall is much more complex, and the article makes a remarkably good job of explaining this complexity. Reporting the more obvious explanations, like:
the discussion moves on to the more subtle policy purpose of identifying buildings with the most opportunity to improve. As the article points out:"Older buildings tend to have higher Energy Star scores because they have thicker walls, fewer windows and less ventilation — superior “thermal envelopes,” as a report on the early results puts it. They are also less suited to energy-gobbling activities like computer data crunching, the downfall of some youthful but middling performers."
"The stakes are considerable. Unlike cities that depend heavily on automobiles, New York racks up most of its carbon dioxide emissions — nearly 80 percent — in heating and cooling buildings. Tracking this energy use is deemed crucial to meeting the city goal of cutting overall emissions by about a third by 2030, to slash costs and fight climate change. "And there lies one of the less well exposed, or perhaps poorly cross-referenced details in an otherwise well informed commentary. However admirable a 2009 law requiring progressive adoption of mandatory disclosure, however sound the approach to market transformation, cutting emissions by 30% is actually a bit of a cop-out. I say this not as some sort of intemperate judgmental rant, but simply to point out that the 2030 Challenge to which so many city mayors in the US have subscribed, sets far more ambitious goals. Still, you have to begin somewhere, and proper, public disclosure, with a suitably reported detailed analysis which does not allow simplistic interpretation, is definitely a good place.
To me as an architect of a certain generation, there are other perhaps predictable, but still shocking factoids, mentioned in passing. My favourite? On a scale topping out at 100, "the Seagram Building, Mies van der Rohe’s bronze-toned 1958 masterpiece on Park Avenue, posted a 3." I shouldn't be surprised.
Read the NY Times article here.
And if you are up to it,download the whole 36 page NEW YORK CITY LOCAL LAW 84 BENCHMARKING REPORT in PDF format here.
Wednesday, 20 February 2013
The Greenest Building in the World
I sometimes like to enter a hyperbole into the Google search terms, just to see what it comes up with. The headline of this blog is one of my favourites. I do it partly because I know you can't expect Google to actually make a technical judgement; that I am only really getting whatever rises like froth to the top of Google's murky PageRank algorithm, sometimes no more than a measure of chutzpah.
And so it seemed this time. The top-ranked page turned out to be an article by Neil Takemoto, writing for the SustainableCitiesCollective web page, about the Bullitt Centre in Seattle. The Bullitt Foundation funds a variety of conservation projects, and committed itself to the rather ambitious Living Building Challenge for its newly built headquarters. The first small crack in the credibility of 'the greenest' claim comes with the realisation that they really only mean it to be that in the company of conventional office buildings.
I should immediately declare that I feel terribly guilty. As one does for being at all negative about anybody's sincere efforts to truly test the envelope of business as usual. The more especially because as I delved deeper I found that the Bullitt Foundation really has made an effort to give access to rich and useful information about the various initiatives and innovative technologies that the building employs. More of that later. Let me get the little negatives off my chest quickly.
In this case, the problem revolves around the contested terms that describe energy self-sufficiency. Thus, the Bullitt Centre is described as Net Zero Energy, while the very first item in the bulleted list of its attributes states that it is "expected to use less than one fourth the energy of a typical building of its size". Whether or not this apparent semantic contradiction confuses, relies on the reader having come across the variety of terms with their different system boundaries, which are used to describe the energy neutrality of buildings. In this case, it is entirely possible that on the one hand the author is describing the energy demand, or energy load of the building, and that both the designers and the users have done well to very significantly reduce that demand. If so, it is plausible that the big photovoltaic array, which tops the building like a peaked baseball cap, could just about generate the electricity portion of that demand. Other initiatives, like the geothermal heating, would help with the rest. Hence Net Zero Energy. But even if that is actually the case, we would be well served by a little additional information: that most likely the building is grid connected and uses the rest of the city as its storage battery, or 'energy flywheel'. My criticism in this regard is really of Takemoto's article.
But the good news is that you can take the trouble to follow the link to the dedicated web page of the building. If you more or less ignore the predictable vision, the tributes to the philanthropic partners, and the on-line leasing pages, you will find a blog. This turns out to have an exhaustive photo record of the construction, with key technologies explained through a collection of informative articles. There is a good selection, from geothermal drilling to the use of timber framing (where conventional office buildings would have steel or concrete). While the information is still a bit ad hoc rather than systematic, it would be churlish to complain too much.
Finally, to give credit where credit is due, Takemoto makes no claim that the building is sustainable, and the web site is reasonably circumspect in its use of the word. In this way, they are much more responsible than the many others who have so corrupted the term, as to make it almost useless.
It's worth linking to the original article, just for the panel that sums up the "20 imperatives of the Living Building Challenge. Read it here.
For a quick primer on Zero energy buildings, you could do worse than Wikipedia here.
And so it seemed this time. The top-ranked page turned out to be an article by Neil Takemoto, writing for the SustainableCitiesCollective web page, about the Bullitt Centre in Seattle. The Bullitt Foundation funds a variety of conservation projects, and committed itself to the rather ambitious Living Building Challenge for its newly built headquarters. The first small crack in the credibility of 'the greenest' claim comes with the realisation that they really only mean it to be that in the company of conventional office buildings.
I should immediately declare that I feel terribly guilty. As one does for being at all negative about anybody's sincere efforts to truly test the envelope of business as usual. The more especially because as I delved deeper I found that the Bullitt Foundation really has made an effort to give access to rich and useful information about the various initiatives and innovative technologies that the building employs. More of that later. Let me get the little negatives off my chest quickly.
In this case, the problem revolves around the contested terms that describe energy self-sufficiency. Thus, the Bullitt Centre is described as Net Zero Energy, while the very first item in the bulleted list of its attributes states that it is "expected to use less than one fourth the energy of a typical building of its size". Whether or not this apparent semantic contradiction confuses, relies on the reader having come across the variety of terms with their different system boundaries, which are used to describe the energy neutrality of buildings. In this case, it is entirely possible that on the one hand the author is describing the energy demand, or energy load of the building, and that both the designers and the users have done well to very significantly reduce that demand. If so, it is plausible that the big photovoltaic array, which tops the building like a peaked baseball cap, could just about generate the electricity portion of that demand. Other initiatives, like the geothermal heating, would help with the rest. Hence Net Zero Energy. But even if that is actually the case, we would be well served by a little additional information: that most likely the building is grid connected and uses the rest of the city as its storage battery, or 'energy flywheel'. My criticism in this regard is really of Takemoto's article.
As I often complain, short online articles give you a sort of hamburger patty version of a hearty T-bone steak and veggies. In most such news items, even on the most committed web sites, fundamental claims for the performance of a building cannot be taken at face value.
But the good news is that you can take the trouble to follow the link to the dedicated web page of the building. If you more or less ignore the predictable vision, the tributes to the philanthropic partners, and the on-line leasing pages, you will find a blog. This turns out to have an exhaustive photo record of the construction, with key technologies explained through a collection of informative articles. There is a good selection, from geothermal drilling to the use of timber framing (where conventional office buildings would have steel or concrete). While the information is still a bit ad hoc rather than systematic, it would be churlish to complain too much.
Finally, to give credit where credit is due, Takemoto makes no claim that the building is sustainable, and the web site is reasonably circumspect in its use of the word. In this way, they are much more responsible than the many others who have so corrupted the term, as to make it almost useless.
It's worth linking to the original article, just for the panel that sums up the "20 imperatives of the Living Building Challenge. Read it here.
For a quick primer on Zero energy buildings, you could do worse than Wikipedia here.
Thursday, 14 February 2013
Yes, Virginia, photovoltaics do work
But for me, as an architect committed to buildings that gobble up less of that generated energy – or better still give back as much as they take – these big news always concentrate too much on the big items like fields of solar collectors working as centralised generators.
I personally think the real future is in building integrated photovoltaics, and the distributed generation which they make possible. Quite frankly, I think that a building with good integrated photovoltaics is just much more sexy than a great big field of concentrating collectors.
Nevertheless, the central issue is how do all those dispersed BIPV integrate with the large-scale energy grid. So I thought it was a good excuse to point interested readers at a surprisingly readable source of information, on how much progress has been made in the world's most committed and advanced market.The European Photovoltaics Industry Association has put out a short version of 'Connecting the Sun'. It is, as I say, a surprisingly readable report on the stuff that a normal architect, or possibly even a normal building engineer may dismiss as all too hard, all too big, and altogether too much somebody else's business. This report is not specifically about buildings. But if you want to bolster your faith in making the effort to integrate photovoltaics into a building that you design, it's well worth the added distraction to at least skim the eighteen pages or so.
Why the odd headline to this post? Well, I live in hope that all those climate change skeptics try reading this little report, too. At least then they would confine themselves to just arguing about the evidence of global warming, but would stop knocking the development of sustainable energy sources. They are good for the planet, and good for us, regardless.
Download the short version of the report here.
Sunday, 27 January 2013
Engineers try to lead towards a greener future
The Australian Institute of Refrigeration, Airconditioning and Heating has apparently decided that they can take a leadership position in working towards a low emission future.
It is easy to see any such initiative as simply jockeying to protect livelihoods in an industry that is popularly perceived as the villain in climate change. But that would be grotesquely unfair for two reasons.
It is all the rest of us who demand the comfort and productivity that increasingly sophisticated environmental controls in buildings can provide. And the truth is that AIRAH has for years promoted a much more vigourous commitment to upskilling and the spread of knowledge related to sustainability amongst its members, than have comparable organisations such as the Institute of Architects.
So it is in interesting to read what they have to say in their Draft Discussion Paper, Transition to Low Emissions HVAC & R, Issues and Solutions. It would be fair to say that nothing the paper is really new, or even for that matter any more sophisticated than the concepts taught to undergraduate architecture and engineering students. A relatively experienced reader would be constantly disturbed by the unavoidable inference that many (or even most) professionals and technical personnel in the industry clearly are not up-to-date with either the rapidly developing technology, or with good practice. But in spite of that, it is refreshing to have the issues brought out into the open.
For instance, the conflicts of interest associated with advocacy of passive design. As the paper says: “Changes that reduce the size and complexity of HVAC & R equipment will reduce revenue for the industry. Fees for ‘low carbon’ advice and analysis need to be separated from HVAC & R design activities,” the paper suggests.
Other highlights of the paper include an exhortation for emphasis on systems rather than equipment, placing the emerging skills shortages in the industry in the context of both the longevity of typical building HCVAC systems and the poor connectivity between design and commissioning, and the need to encourage uptake of building information management (BIM).
For a relatively brief and supportive review, including an interview with Phil Wilkinson, chief executive of AIRAH, try these two articles in TheFifthEstate (from which the image above is taken):
For meatier reading, try the real thing here even if it is too late for comments after February 1.
It is easy to see any such initiative as simply jockeying to protect livelihoods in an industry that is popularly perceived as the villain in climate change. But that would be grotesquely unfair for two reasons.
It is all the rest of us who demand the comfort and productivity that increasingly sophisticated environmental controls in buildings can provide. And the truth is that AIRAH has for years promoted a much more vigourous commitment to upskilling and the spread of knowledge related to sustainability amongst its members, than have comparable organisations such as the Institute of Architects.
So it is in interesting to read what they have to say in their Draft Discussion Paper, Transition to Low Emissions HVAC & R, Issues and Solutions. It would be fair to say that nothing the paper is really new, or even for that matter any more sophisticated than the concepts taught to undergraduate architecture and engineering students. A relatively experienced reader would be constantly disturbed by the unavoidable inference that many (or even most) professionals and technical personnel in the industry clearly are not up-to-date with either the rapidly developing technology, or with good practice. But in spite of that, it is refreshing to have the issues brought out into the open.
For instance, the conflicts of interest associated with advocacy of passive design. As the paper says: “Changes that reduce the size and complexity of HVAC & R equipment will reduce revenue for the industry. Fees for ‘low carbon’ advice and analysis need to be separated from HVAC & R design activities,” the paper suggests.
Other highlights of the paper include an exhortation for emphasis on systems rather than equipment, placing the emerging skills shortages in the industry in the context of both the longevity of typical building HCVAC systems and the poor connectivity between design and commissioning, and the need to encourage uptake of building information management (BIM).
For a relatively brief and supportive review, including an interview with Phil Wilkinson, chief executive of AIRAH, try these two articles in TheFifthEstate (from which the image above is taken):
For meatier reading, try the real thing here even if it is too late for comments after February 1.
Wednesday, 26 December 2012
American architects embrace energy modelling?
Well, if not today, maybe tomorrow.
I was trying to read the subscription on-line copy of the November/December issue of Eco-structure, an American Institute of Architects magazine. My irritation with the avalanche of advertisements was shading out my interest in all the new technologies and initiatives they were trying to bring to my attention. And then, I came across 'AIA Perspective', by Jeff Potter, the 2012 President of the Institute.
Jeff was really only doing the marketing for An Architect’s Guide to Integrating Energy Modeling in the Design Process, published in October. For that he apologizes, then makes an impassioned plea for his fellow practitioners. I can't give you a live link to the article, so I take the liberty of quoting extensively from his statement:
By not making a credible, evidence-based claim for performance, we are abdicating our responsibility to both the client and the user. This will further erode our reputation as well as the value of our work. Furthermore, if we do not have a firm grasp on how our buildings will actually, not theoretically, perform, it will have a negative impact on the quality of what we design. What’s the alternative? A good beginning is to learn the ABCs of energy modeling.
This is the point where eyes glaze over. Energy modeling sounds boring and wonkish. Yet architecture is not just the thrill of shaping form; it’s also the science of delivering value. We do ourselves, our profession, and, frankly, other members of the building team a disservice if we acknowledge only the aesthetics and leave the question of performance to someone else. Being able to say how a design works has historically been part of what we do for our clients. These days it may be the leading question clients ask. The challenge of climate change and the smart allocation of limited and increasingly scarce resources offer new opportunities to reassert our responsibility.The message closely echoes my own concerns about architects, and recent developments in the provision of architectural services. At the moment, the initiative to move in the direction Jeff Potter advocates is unlikely to be led from the architecture schools, where the capacity to deliver courses in the science of architecture is arguably at historic lows. But professionals could, if they see the urgency of his message, devote some of their compulsory professional development to the cause. If you want to change the balance of your professional reading, you can do worse than bookmark http://www.eco-structure.com/.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


